You may have heard that the Archdiocese of Philadelphia is closing churches. It has been in the news of late but there has been very little follow-up except to say that people are naturally unhappy.
Frankford (a neighborhood in Northeast Philadelphia with a population of about 50,000) is in a unique situation in that the two churches in the heart of Frankford, Mater Dolorosa and St. Joachim, are both being closed. They are within a few blocks of one another and both are in the the poorest area of Frankford. However, both of those churches are financially independent thanks to the astute financial management of their pastors, Father John Large and Father Steve Wetzel.
During the period while this issue was being studied, people in Frankford thought that the two churches would eventually have to merge. They were prepared for that likelihood but the announcement that both would be closed was sad and puzzling.
So, naturally, they are asking a very simple question of Archbishop Charles Chaput. Why is the Archdiocese closing two financially sound parishes and abandoning the Catholic population in Frankford? They are being cut loose without the slightest care for the hardships the parishioners may endure as a result of this callous treatment by their Church. Many are seniors on fixed incomes. Some are physically disabled. All are the faithful that have stuck with their church over these past years of scandal and shame caused by that same Archdiocese. Now they are being treated like criminals rather than the victims of a money driven Archdiocesan Planning Committee.
So what happened to bring this about? Father Tom Higgins, Pastor of Holy Innocents Catholic Church and Dean of Deanery 12, Lower Northeast Philadelphia, has indicated that he made a proposal to the Archdiocesan Strategic Planning Committee to close one of the Frankford parishes and merge the other into it. He has said that he believed Frankford should retain a Catholic Church. His proposal was rejected.
He then offered an alternate proposal to close both parishes and merge them into St. Bartholomew in Wissinoming. That also was rejected. The end was dictated by the Archdiocesan Planning Committee that both Churches along with another, St. Joan of Arc, would all be merged into Holy Innocents.
Well, if they did not listen to the Dean, who did they listen to? It might have been the cash register. We can’t say for sure but that is the only reasonable explanation for this crazy idea. It’s like a corporate raider has taken over the Catholic Church. The parish’s assets are worth more liquidated than operating. Those stained glass windows in these old churches alone are of significant value. The land and buildings, even in Frankford, are going to bring in cash.
Given that the Archdiocese is bleeding red ink, this makes it too tempting. Why leave these working class parishes continue when their assets can be put to use supporting other favored projects, like paying off lawsuits, legal fees and making up the deficient pension system for retiring priests.
Sounds like Gordon Gecko in a Roman collar. For their sake, let’s hope that Jesus doesn’t turn up at 222 N. 17th street any time soon. I can’t imagine he would approve that the occupants have placed the god of money above the welfare of souls.